The Winfield Choke Out

In the first inning, the altercation was sparked when Norris threw a high, inside fastball to Winfield. The pitch, perceived as a knockdown pitch aimed at intimidating or possibly injuring the star outfielder, was not taken lightly. Winfield, known for his competitive spirit, immediately objected to what he viewed as a dangerous pitch. According to reports, Winfield reacted strongly, and his frustration quickly turned into action. He moved toward the mound, where Norris was standing, but Mike Heath, the A’s catcher, stepped in to block his path, preventing a direct confrontation with Norris. What ensued was a chaotic scene in front of the mound, as Winfield grabbed Heath by the throat, igniting a bench-clearing brawl.

Home-plate umpire Derryl Cousins, witnessing the incident unfold, wasted no time in making a decision. He ejected Winfield from the game, citing him as the instigator of the fight. According to Cousins, Winfield’s aggressive response to the pitch and his actions toward Heath were the catalysts for the bench-clearing altercation. While the physical confrontation was quickly broken up, the tension lingered for the remainder of the game, and the fallout extended far beyond the final out.

In typical fashion, Yankees owner George Steinbrenner, never one to shy away from controversy, inserted himself into the conversation despite not being at the game. Shortly after the incident, Steinbrenner issued a scathing statement criticizing the umpires’ handling of the situation, particularly Cousins’ decision to eject Winfield. Steinbrenner was outraged that his star player had been tossed from the game, especially when he believed that Norris’ pitch was intentionally provocative and dangerous.

Steinbrenner’s criticism drew a swift and pointed response from Lee MacPhail, then the president of the American League. MacPhail issued his own statement, condemning Steinbrenner’s remarks and promising disciplinary action against the outspoken owner. MacPhail described Steinbrenner’s comments as “intemperate” and emphasized that such public criticism of umpires would not be tolerated. MacPhail’s statement made it clear that a careful review of the events would lead to consequences for Steinbrenner, whose tendency to speak out about league matters had landed him in hot water before.

Not one to back down, Steinbrenner doubled down on his comments later that evening, issuing a second statement in which he denied that his remarks had been excessive. He maintained that his criticism of the umpires was based on “what I believe to be fact.” Despite the threat of disciplinary action, Steinbrenner stood firm in his defense of Winfield and his belief that the umpires had mishandled the situation. This back-and-forth between Steinbrenner and MacPhail added an extra layer of drama to an already tumultuous evening at Yankee Stadium.

The Aftermath

The incident also brought attention to the growing tensions between the Yankees and their opponents, as well as between Steinbrenner and Major League Baseball officials. Steinbrenner’s reputation for speaking out against umpires and league officials had long been a contentious issue, and this episode only added fuel to the fire.

For Dave Winfield, the incident on May 27, 1983, was a rare blemish on an otherwise stellar career. Known for his professionalism and immense talent, Winfield’s actions that day were a testament to his fiery competitiveness. Though he was ejected, many fans and analysts sympathized with his reaction to the dangerous pitch. Norris’ inside fastball had crossed an unspoken line, and Winfield’s response, while aggressive, was seen by some as a defense of his own safety. The confrontation between Winfield and Heath remains one of the more memorable moments from the 1983 season. It highlighted the fine line between competitive intensity and outright conflict, as well as the ongoing debate over the role of “brushback” pitches and player safety. The fight also underscored the volatile relationship between George Steinbrenner and MLB officials, a relationship that would continue to generate headlines throughout Steinbrenner’s tenure as Yankees owner.

Lee MacPhail’s stern rebuke of Steinbrenner reflected the league’s desire to maintain control and discipline over its teams, even when powerful owners like Steinbrenner challenged its authority. Ultimately, the May 27 game was not just about a fight on the field—it was a microcosm of the larger battles being waged off the field between the Yankees and Major League Baseball.

The May 27, 1983, clash between Dave Winfield and Mike Heath, set against the backdrop of George Steinbrenner’s outspoken criticism and Lee MacPhail’s measured response, serves as a reminder of the high stakes and intense emotions that often accompany professional baseball. The incident remains a significant moment in Yankees history, a blend of athletic confrontation, ownership drama, and league politics that defined an era for the Bronx Bombers.

–Alvin Izzo
BYB Yankee History Contributor