Why the Prosperity Gospel is Heretical

Understanding Theological Error vs. Heresy

Theological Error: This refers to incorrect or flawed interpretations of biblical teachings that do not necessarily disrupt the essential tenets of the Christian faith. Errors can lead to misunderstandings and misapplications of biblical principles but do not sever one’s standing within the Christian community. Examples include debates over eschatological views (e.g., premillennialism vs. amillennialism) or modes of baptism (immersion vs. sprinkling).

Heresy: Heresy, on the other hand, is a belief or opinion that fundamentally contradicts the core doctrines of Christianity as defined by historic creeds and councils, such as the Nicene Creed. Heresies undermine essential aspects of the faith, including the nature of God, the person and work of Jesus Christ, the Trinity, and salvation. They represent a significant departure from foundational Christian beliefs. Examples include Arianism (denial of Christ’s deity) and Sabellianism (rejection of the Trinity).

Why the Prosperity Gospel is Heretical

The prosperity gospel is considered heresy because it fundamentally distorts the core doctrines of Christianity by promoting a false gospel and presenting a false Christ. This teaching asserts that faith in Jesus guarantees physical health, wealth, and success, which starkly contradicts the biblical message that emphasizes spiritual blessings, eternal salvation, and often suffering for Christ.

This false gospel shifts the focus from the redemptive work of Christ and the call to self-denial and discipleship to a materialistic pursuit of earthly gains. It presents a Christ who primarily serves to fulfill personal desires for prosperity rather than the Savior who redeems humanity from sin. By doing so, the prosperity gospel undermines the true nature of Christ’s mission and the essence of the Christian faith, leading believers away from the authentic message of salvation and sanctification as taught in Scripture.

In essence, the prosperity gospel replaces the central message of the cross with a promise of earthly wealth, which is not only misleading but spiritually dangerous. It detracts from the sacrificial and transformative nature of the gospel, which calls believers to follow Christ in humility, often through trials and suffering, with the promise of eternal, not necessarily temporal, rewards.

Recognizing the prosperity gospel as heresy rather than mere theological error is crucial because it highlights the gravity of its deviation from orthodox Christianity. It serves as a reminder to remain vigilant in preserving the integrity of the gospel message, ensuring it remains centered on Christ’s redemptive work and the eternal hope it offers.

END

Why the Prosperity Gospel is Heretical

By J. Neil Daniel
August 15, 2024

As a student of Christian theology, I have often reflected on the profound differences between theological error and heresy, and I am convinced that the prosperity gospel falls into the latter category.

Defining Terms

The prosperity gospel, also known as the “health and wealth gospel” or “word of faith movement,” is a theological belief that teaches that faith in Jesus Christ, along with positive speech and donations to certain ministries, will lead to physical health, wealth, and success. This doctrine emphasizes material prosperity and well-being as a sign of God’s favor and often equates financial blessing with spiritual growth.