We're Watching The Al East Slip Away

 The Blue Jays will not go quietly.

Benching Anthony Volpe? Absolutely the right call. Starting José Caballero at short? Also the right call. The Yankees winning? Well… that should be the easy part, but somehow, they still find ways to fumble it.

At this point, I can’t even bring myself to blame the players anymore. This isn’t just about slumps or injuries — it’s about a franchise drowning in its own mismanagement all season. We were backed into a corner. The obsession with analytics, projections, and “modeling outcomes” has sucked the life out of this team. Aaron Boone? Half the time he looks like he’s solving a Rubik’s Cube blindfolded in the dugout.

And don’t even get me started on that whole Astros series sideshow — the Yankees whining about an “anti-Yankee” umpire conspiracy,  the Ryan McMahon “did he or didn’t he” catch fiasco… Grow up.

Brian Walsh ruled that Ryan McMahon didn’t catch this ball and after some dialogue the call stood pic.twitter.com/WcPI0n6Nc5

— Jomboy Media (@JomboyMedia) September 5, 2025

We clearly got squeezed in the Astros series.  There is NOTHING WE CAN DO ABOUT IT. This team sounds like a toddler blaming the teacher for losing recess privileges. Umpires aren’t our problem, boys. I didn’t even write about it on BYB, because the whole thing was stupid.

Here’s the reality check: the Yankees are backed into a corner, clawing at excuses like they’re clinging to a life raft. Complaining about bad calls isn’t going to save this season. Winning games against the Blue Jays, Red Sox, and Tigers might. But, sure, keep crying about the ump while Toronto casually slaps you around.

Last night was another lesson in humility. Kevin Gausman completely dismantled the Yankees’ bats — seven innings, three hits, five strikeouts, and the only damage was Stanton’s solo homer. That’s it. That’s the game. Cam Schlittler? He was due for a rough outing, and Toronto made sure it arrived on schedule.

Bo Bichette, meanwhile, continues to make Yankee pitching look like batting practice. Broken-bat RBI double. Sacrifice fly. Crushing souls on repeat. The Blue Jays have now beaten the Yankees eight times in 11 meetings this year and flipped the division race on its head. Back in May, Toronto was eight games behind. Now? They’re not.

Forget conspiracy theories. Forget bad umps. Forget the excuses. The Yankees have a Blue Jays problem, a Boone problem, and — let’s be real — a reality problem.

Right now, they’re four games back. Four games, a manager on autopilot, and a fan base clinging to umpire drama like it’s gospel. 

It’s pathetic.