Don't Be Fooled By Volpe's Hot Start

Jose Caballero should remain the Yankees’ everyday shortstop, regardless of Anthony Volpe’s latest hot start. If that sounds harsh, it’s only because Yankees fans have watched the same cycle play out enough times to recognize it immediately.

Volpe starts hot. Headlines follow. Social media fills with breakout-season predictions. Analysts begin talking about the former top prospect finally putting it all together. Then somewhere along the way, the production starts to disappear, pitchers adjust, and the numbers begin trending in the wrong direction.

At some point, a trend stops being a coincidence and becomes part of the scouting report.

The best example remains 2024. Through his first 264 plate appearances, Volpe looked like a completely different hitter, batting .282 and appearing ready to establish himself as one of the league’s better young shortstops. Then the league adjusted. Over the remainder of the season, he hit just .221/.256/.325. That’s not a slump. That’s a collapse.

To Volpe’s credit, he delivered some huge postseason moments, including a memorable World Series grand slam. Nobody can take that away from him, except for the fact that the Yankees lost, and so, it really means nothing. One October highlight doesn’t automatically erase years of offensive inconsistency. The Yankees cannot continue making lineup decisions based on what they hope Volpe will become rather than what he has consistently shown himself to be. But that’s what Boone does.

Meanwhile, Jose Caballero keeps doing something that has become strangely undervalued in today’s game: he shows up every day and performs.  Caballero doesn’t arrive with the prospect hype. He doesn’t have the first-round pedigree. He isn’t the player featured in marketing campaigns or pushed as the face of the franchise’s future. All he does is play winning baseball.

His defense is elite. His instincts are exceptional. He makes routine plays look effortless and difficult plays look routine. His baseball IQ consistently shows up in every phase of the game. Whether it’s positioning, anticipation, baserunning, situational awareness, or simply understanding how to execute winning baseball, Caballero brings a level of polish and consistency that the Yankees have desperately needed.

Even Friday night against the Athletics provided another example. Back at shortstop, Caballero went 2-for-4 with a run scored in the Yankees’ 8-2 win. It wasn’t a headline-grabbing performance. It was something even better: reliable.

That’s become his trademark. But here’s another one. Saturday? Volpe? 0-4 in the Yankees loss to the A’s. I can’t deal.

Plus, the defensive conversation should not even be close at this point. If we’re being completely honest, the Yankees’ strongest infield alignment features Jazz Chisholm at second base and Jose Caballero at shortstop.

Chisholm is simply a better defensive second baseman than Volpe. His range, athleticism, reactions, and comfort level at the position are evident every night. Likewise, Caballero has shown superior consistency at shortstop. Together, they give the Yankees an athletic, dependable middle infield capable of turning difficult plays into outs on a regular basis.

Which brings us to the strange sight of Volpe taking ground balls at both shortstop and second base before games. For optics, it makes sense. For baseball reasons, it makes far less sense.

The Yankees may want fans to believe they’re exploring versatility, but it’s difficult to envision a realistic scenario where Volpe becomes the preferred option at second base. Why would he?

If Chisholm is the better second baseman and Caballero is the better shortstop, where exactly does Volpe fit into that equation? You don’t weaken two positions just to create room for one player, unless of course you’re obsessed with Volpe like Boone is.

For years, the Yankees have seemed determined to make Volpe work regardless of performance. They’ve remained patient through prolonged offensive struggles, extended slumps, and repeated second-half fadeouts. At some point, however, patience has to be rewarded with results.

This season should be viewed as a proving ground for Volpe. If he truly has turned the corner, fantastic. Let him prove it over six months instead of six weeks. Because history suggests caution.

Pitchers have consistently followed the same blueprint against him. Early in seasons, they challenge him with fastballs and he takes advantage. Then scouting reports circulate. Opposing staffs identify the holes in his swing and stop giving him pitches he can drive.

The diet shifts toward breaking balls and off-speed offerings. His chase rate begins to climb. His hard-hit rates begin to fall. His swing often gets longer. His strike-zone discipline deteriorates. Weak ground balls start replacing line drives. The production dries up. The pattern has become so familiar that many Yankees fans can practically predict it before it happens.

That doesn’t mean Volpe lacks talent. Quite the opposite. The raw tools are obvious. The speed is real. The athleticism is real. The defensive flashes are real. The consistency is not. And consistency is what separates good players from cornerstone players. It’s my opinion the minors is where he needs to be to get consistency.

Jose Caballero has earned the opportunity to keep playing every day because he has consistently impacted games. Not because of prospect rankings. Not because of draft status. Not because of organizational investment.

Because he has performed.

The Yankees’ best defensive alignment right now is staring them directly in the face: Jazz Chisholm at second base, Jose Caballero at shortstop, and everyone else figuring out how to fit around that reality.

If Anthony Volpe wants that shortstop job back permanently, the path is simple. Sustain the production. Make the adjustments. Prove that this year’s hot start won’t become another chapter in a story Yankees fans have already read multiple times.

Until that happens, Caballero deserves the job, and frankly, he deserves far more credit than he’s getting for being one of the most reliable players on the roster.

Source: http://bleedingyankeeblue.blogspot.com/2026/05/dont-be-fooled-by-volpes-hot-start.html