Cashman & Boone Should Both Apologize... To All Of Us Yankee Fans

Aroldis Chapman wants Brian Cashman to apologize to him.

And honestly? He probably should.

Actually, while we’re handing out apologies, Cashman and Boone might want to issue a few to Yankees fans too.

For years now, especially during the Aaron Boone era, these haven’t felt like the Yankees most fans grew up watching. The Core Four years gave fans legends they’ll be talking about forever. When people look back on this generation of Yankees, Aaron Judge is probably the only player guaranteed to get that same treatment. No championships and we are wasting time.

The rest of the guys? Too often it’s felt like a roster held together with duct tape, bargain-bin fixes, and crossed fingers. Every season begins with championship dreams and ends with fans staring blankly at their televisions wondering what went wrong this time.

But this story isn’t really about us. It’s about Chapman.

And I have to admit, I respect the balls. The man wants an apology from Cashman before he’d even consider a reunion in New York. That’s some next-level nerve, and you’ve got to appreciate it.

The disagreement goes back to the 2022 postseason when Chapman was left off the Yankees’ ALDS roster after missing a team workout and flying to Miami. According to Chapman, he had permission from the organization to make the trip. If that’s true, then his frustration makes perfect sense.

And let’s be honest: does anyone really think it’s impossible that the Yankees gave him the green light and then later acted like the whole thing was his fault? Fans have seen stranger things from this organization over the years.

Of course, Cashman and Boone have consistently maintained that Chapman did not have permission to skip the mandatory workout, which is why he was excluded from the playoff roster. That’s been the Yankees’ version of events from the beginning.

But here’s the bigger question: why is any of this suddenly a major story?

From a pure baseball standpoint, bringing Chapman back would actually make some sense. The Yankees bullpen has been a roller coaster, and Chapman is pitching better than several relievers currently occupying spots. He could help stabilize the late innings immediately.

The problem is that none of that matters because the Yankees aren’t bringing him back.

Which makes this entire debate feel like arguing over where to put the furniture in a house nobody is buying.

Chapman wants an apology. Cashman isn’t giving one. A reunion isn’t happening. Everyone knows it.

So let’s call this what it is: a funny little baseball sideshow in the middle of the season. Entertaining? Sure. Meaningful? Not really.

It’s a non-story.

And a pretty silly one at that.

Source: http://bleedingyankeeblue.blogspot.com/2026/06/cashman-boone-should-both-apologize-to.html