What Role Could Will Warren Play?

As the Yankees navigate a pivotal offseason, one name to keep an eye on is right-hander Will Warren. While the team continues to evaluate its rotation and trade possibilities, including rumors involving Marcus Stroman, Warren stands out as a potential solution for the back end of the starting rotation. If the Yankees opt to hold onto him, Warren could become a significant factor in 2025.

Projected as the sixth man in the rotation, Warren is expected to step up as needed, especially if injuries strike. MLB.com recently highlighted his development:

“Warren initially struggled with the automated ball and strike system when he got to Triple-A last May but adapted and provided consistent strikes in the last two months. His command isn’t as sharp as his control, and refining his ability to locate his pitches will be the final step of his development. Though he’s not very physical, he has added strength and been durable as a pro, bolstering his chances of becoming a No. 4 starter.”

While I believe that the Yankees may eventually trade Warren, his readiness to fill gaps in the rotation—particularly if Stroman is dealt—makes him an appealing option for the team to retain. His growth trajectory suggests he could exceed expectations and potentially become a reliable mid-rotation starter.

Look, Warren’s rise through the Yankees’ system has been impressive. After concluding his college career at Southeastern Louisiana in 2021 with three straight double-digit strikeout games and a fastball touching 98 mph, he quickly emerged as one of the organization’s top pitching prospects. Selected in the eighth round of the 2021 draft, Warren benefited from adjustments to his arsenal, including the addition of a sinker and upgrades to his slider.

He climbed to Double-A just two months into his 2022 pro debut and ended last season by allowing only two runs in his final five Triple-A starts. His slider, which wasn’t a significant part of his college repertoire, now features increased velocity and lift, evolving into a devastating mid-80s sweeper with spin rates exceeding 3,000 rpm.

Warren complements his slider with two- and four-seam fastballs in the 92-95 mph range, occasionally touching 97. His heavy sinker generates ground balls effectively, while his mid-80s changeup shows promise despite occasional inconsistency.

I believe that if the Yankees decide to keep Warren, his versatility and potential durability could address pressing needs in the rotation. His ability to step in as a sixth starter or provide insurance against injuries offers the team flexibility. Moreover, his developmental upside hints at a higher ceiling than the typical back-end starter.

While trading Warren for a more established piece might be tempting in my opinion, the Yankees could benefit greatly from investing in his future. If given the opportunity to solidify his role, Warren might not just fill gaps but also establish himself as a vital contributor for years to come.

We shall see.