The 2025 Yankees Will Be A Success & Boone Will Have Nothing To Do With It

 Aaron Boone is hailed by some as a capable leader, but let’s cut through the noise—Boone is overrated, inexperienced, and lacks the critical skills needed to lead the Yankees to a championship. Sure, he may be friendly with his players, but being a buddy doesn’t equate to being a great manager when the stakes are high. If Boone were truly exceptional, the Yankees might have celebrated a World Series victory by now. But the harsh reality is that the Yankees’ recent successes are a testament to the talent of players like Aaron Judge and Juan Soto, not Boone’s strategy.

When the going gets tough, Boone’s inability to problem-solve becomes glaringly obvious. He doesn’t think like a manager; he acts like a fanboy starstruck by his proximity to the Yankees. It’s pathetic. Boone is more focused on being in the inner circle than on making the tough calls that championship-caliber teams need. And now, the audacity to believe an extension is in the works? That’s laughable.

Enter Emmanuel Berbari, a baseball analyst who seems enamored with Boone’s tenure. In a passionate statement, Berbari exclaimed, “Four more years, Aaron Boone. I don’t want a lame duck entering this season; I want a mandate for Boone.” Berbari credits Boone with consistently getting the most out of his teams, praising him for reaching the ALCS with the best roster on paper in the AL.

What Berbari fails to grasp is that players like Aaron Judge won’t publicly criticize their manager, especially not Boone, who “backs the players.” But backing the players doesn’t mean Boone knows how to manage. The Yankees have shown they can compete with the best, but under Boone, they haven’t reached the pinnacle. If Boone were truly elite, the Yankees would have more than a few playoff runs—they’d have championships.

Berbari needs to take a long walk and rethink his stance. His blind support for Boone overlooks the critical flaws that keep the Yankees from greatness. Boone isn’t the mastermind behind the team’s success; he’s just riding the coattails of an immensely talented roster. It’s time to face the truth—Aaron Boone is not the manager who will lead the Yankees to the top.

There. Who all who asked where my anger for Boone went, it’s still there… there was just so much great rumor mill stuff coming out I got side tracked! Happy Thursday!