Exploring The Pros And Cons Of Using Once Fired Brass And New Brass For Reloading

Aaron Spuler is a firearms enthusiast and recreational shooter. Follow more or his work at The Weapon Blog

Have you ever wondered which is better for reloading – once fired brass or new brass?

Each option has its own set of pros and cons. Once fired brass is often cheaper and widely available. It can also save you money over time.

However, it may not always match the precision of new brass. On the other hand, new brass offers consistency and reliability. It’s up to you to decide what best fits your needs.

Ready to learn more about the differences? Let’s dive in!

Pros of Using Once Fired Brass

When considering once fired brass, several advantages stand out for those looking to optimize their reloading process. Here are some of them:

Cost Savings

One of the key benefits of using once fired brass is the cost savings it provides. Once fired brass is typically available at a lower price compared to new brass. This can make a big difference for reloaders who are on a budget. Buying bulk brass can further reduce costs, as purchasing in larger quantities often comes with discounts. Many shooters find that sourcing once fired brass from local ranges or online dealers saves them money in the long run.

Additionally, since once fired brass is often available in various calibers, it can be easier to find what you need. This flexibility can be useful in maintaining your shooting practice without breaking the bank. Ultimately, cost savings are a significant advantage that makes once fired brass appealing for many reloaders.

Better Availability

Once fired brass is often more accessible than new brass, making it a popular choice among shooting enthusiasts. Many gun ranges and shooting events provide once fired brass for sale. This means you can find a variety of calibers without much effort. In some cases, shooting enthusiasts can even gather their own once fired brass during shooting sessions. This can be convenient and cost-effective.

Additionally, local gun shops and online retailers often stock once fired brass in bulk. The wide availability helps you to reload without worrying about supply shortages. With once fired brass, you have the flexibility to experiment with different loads and bullets. This aspect can enhance your shooting experience and keep costs manageable.

Environmental Impact

Using once fired brass has a positive effect on the environment. By reusing brass cases, you help reduce waste. When you use new brass, you contribute to mining and manufacturing processes that can harm the ecosystem. Reusing once fired brass means fewer resources are used in production. This helps conserve energy and water, which are vital for our planet.

Additionally, recycling brass reduces the amount of metal that ends up in landfills. Each time you choose once fired brass, you are making a small, eco-friendly choice. This means shooters can enjoy their hobby while being more responsible.

Cons of Using Once Fired Brass

As with any option, there are also some potential downsides to using once fired brass for reloading. Let’s take a look at a few of them:

Inconsistent Quality

One of the main drawbacks of using once fired brass is the inconsistent quality it may exhibit. Each piece of brass can vary in condition, which can affect performance. Some cases might show signs of wear or damage from previous use. This variability can lead to issues such as case splitting or inconsistent pressure during firing.

Reloaders may find that some brass requires more cleaning or inspection compared to new brass. Additionally, once fired brass may not provide the same level of precision as a new batch. This inconsistency can impact accuracy, which is crucial for target shooting and hunting. For those who prioritize uniformity in their loads, this can be a significant concern.

Unknown History

Another disadvantage of using once fired brass is the unknown history of each case. When you use once fired brass, you often have no way of knowing how many times it has been fired before. This can lead to concerns about its previous use and overall reliability.

Some cases may have been subjected to excessive pressure or poor care. This unknown history can make it harder to trust the durability of the brass. Without insight into how the brass was handled, reloaders may face unexpected failures. This is especially important for those who engage in precision shooting or hunting. Inconsistent histories can lead to safety issues.

Limited Lifespan

One of the key concerns with using once fired brass is its limited lifespan. Unlike new brass, which is manufactured to high standards, once fired brass has already been subjected to the stresses of firing. Over time, this can lead to fatigue in the metal, which may cause the cases to fail. Reloaders need to monitor the condition of once fired brass closely.

Signs of wear can include cracks, thinning walls, or deformation. These issues can affect the safety and performance of the load. As such, it is essential to inspect each piece of brass before reloading. Many experts recommend limiting the number of times brass can be reloaded. This precaution can help ensure consistent performance and keep you safe while shooting.

Pros of Using New Brass

Just like with once fired brass, there are also many advantages to using new brass for reloading. Here are some of the most significant benefits:

Consistent Performance

New brass is known for its consistent performance, making it a preferred choice for many reloaders. Each case is manufactured to strict standards, ensuring uniformity across the board. This consistency helps achieve better accuracy, which is important for target shooting and hunting. Reloaders can trust that new brass will behave predictably under pressure.

Unlike once fired brass, new cases do not have any previous history that could affect their quality. This means users can expect reliable performance every time they reload. Additionally, new brass often requires less preparation work, as it typically comes clean and in good condition. This can save time and effort for reloaders.

Enhanced Precision

Using new brass for reloading significantly enhances precision. Each piece of new brass is crafted with exact specifications. This leads to better uniformity in dimensions and weight. Reloaders appreciate this consistency when developing their loads. When the brass is uniform, it helps achieve tighter groupings on the target. It also allows for precise pressure control during firing.

As a result, shooters can confidently predict how their ammunition will perform. New brass can minimize errors and fluctuations that might arise from using once fired brass.

Longer Lifespan

New brass has a longer lifespan compared to once fired brass. Since it is manufactured from fresh materials, it does not have the wear and tear associated with previous firing. This durability means that new brass can be reloaded more times without failing.

Reloaders can expect their new brass to hold up under repeated use. This can lead to fewer concerns about safety or performance issues. Additionally, the longevity of new brass can make it a more cost-effective choice in the long run. Many shooters find that investing in new brass pays off over time.

Cons of Using New Brass

While there are many benefits to using new brass for reloading, there are also a few potential downsides to consider. Here are some of them:

Higher Cost

One of the main disadvantages of using new brass is the higher cost associated with it. New brass typically costs more than once fired brass. This can be a significant barrier for reloaders on a budget. Many enthusiasts might find it hard to justify spending extra money on new brass. While the higher price can lead to better quality, it may not be feasible for everyone.

Reloaders need to factor this cost into their overall budget. This expense can add up quickly, especially for those who reload frequently. It may limit how much ammunition you can afford to create.

Availability Issues

The availability of new brass can sometimes pose challenges for reloaders. Unlike once fired brass, which is widely accessible, new brass may not always be in stock. Reloaders might encounter shortages of specific calibers that they need. This can be frustrating, especially for those who prefer new brass for its consistency and quality.

Many manufacturers face high demand, which can lead to delays in production. As a result, reloaders may have to wait for restocks or explore different brands. Shopping online can help find new brass, but it might come with shipping delays. Local gun shops may not always have a robust selection of new brass either.

Potential Over-Engineering

One concern with using new brass is the potential for over-engineering. Sometimes, manufacturers may produce brass with features that are unnecessary for the average reloader. This can lead to cases that are heavier or more complex than needed.

While these enhancements might appeal to a few users, they can also increase the cost. Many reloaders seek simplicity and efficiency in their equipment. Over-engineered brass might require additional adjustments or calibration. This can complicate the reloading process and slow down production.

Learn More About Once Fired Brass

It is often cheaper and more available than new brass, making it a great option for those who want to save money and keep a steady supply. However, there are some challenges, such as the time needed to clean and check the brass for quality.

Despite these issues, many reloaders find that once fired brass works well for their needs. By carefully looking after the cases, you can enjoy your shooting experience while being kind to your wallet and the environment.