Maybe Austin Wells Just Isn't Good

At some point, you have to stop calling it a slump.

Austin Wells is hitting .175. He hit .219 last year and .229 the year before that. His career average sits around .213.

Folks, maybe this isn’t a season-long slump. Maybe Austin Wells just isn’t that good. I know. The framing. The defense. The underlying metrics. The expected numbers. I’ve heard it all.

Wonderful. Maybe the Yankees can hang a TRYING banner in Monument Park.

Eventually your starting catcher has to hit the baseball. Wells has struggled making consistent contact, his power has disappeared for long stretches, and left-handed pitching has made him look completely overmatched. But my bigger problem isn’t Wells.

It’s the Yankees scouts. What the hell are these people evaluating? Seriously. Because we’re watching the Anthony Volpe disaster unfold at the same time. Another highly touted Yankee prospect. Another player we were told was going to be a cornerstone. Another organization-favorite whose actual major-league production never matched the hype.

At what point does somebody investigate the people making these evaluations?

Because Wells and Volpe aren’t 17-year-old lottery tickets anymore. We’ve seen them against major-league pitching. The results matter. Yet the Yankees continually seem more interested in scouting what a player might become than acknowledging what he’s actually become.

That’s dangerous. And it’s becoming a pattern. Potential. Projections. Exit velocity. Athleticism. Makeup. Upside.

How about hits? Wells has shown occasional stretches where the bat comes alive. Great. But a few hot weeks don’t erase years of mediocre offensive production. And apparently Wells does have one elite evaluation skill.

Burritos.  The guy became a social-media hit reviewing breakfast burritos and grading them on a 100-point scale. Maybe the Yankees should put him in the scouting department.

At least Wells appears capable of identifying the difference between an 87-point burrito and a 73-point burrito. I’m increasingly unconvinced Yankee scouts can identify the difference between a legitimate everyday major leaguer and another prospect they’re desperately hoping becomes one.

That’s the problem. We heard the hype with Volpe. We’re hearing the excuses with Wells.

Meanwhile, Yankee fans are supposed to wait patiently while the organization tells us their internal numbers see something our eyes apparently don’t.

Enough. Sometimes a slump is a slump.

And sometimes the scouts simply got the player wrong.

Maybe that’s Austin Wells. Maybe that’s Anthony Volpe. And maybe the Yankees need to stop grading their prospects and start taking a very serious look at the people doing the grading.

Source: http://bleedingyankeeblue.blogspot.com/2026/08/maybe-austin-wells-just-isnt-good.html