The Spencer Jones & "ohtani Like" Hype Kick-off Spring Training!

It was a big spring debut this weekend for Spencer Jones. It came with the expected shiny moment that showcased the enormous potential that Jones advocates would expect. It was also followed by the frustration we’ve seen on repeat the last couple of seasons. But now, Jones has a new batting approach and a new comparison to live up to?

There’s been so much talk about Jones and his enormous potential over recent years. We all salivate over the potential of a new addition to this Yankees team that has five tool potential and can catapult this team to the next level. Now he has worked on his mechanics and a swing that has been called “almost Shohei Ohtani-like,” read more HERE. 

The new “Ohtani-like” swing was seen Saturday with a gigantic home run that cleared right field and left the stadium. It was all of the excitement you could ask for in a first at bat of a new season, but it was followed by reminders of the past with two strikeouts in the following plate appearances. As much as I want to see Jones hit those exciting home runs, I want to see consistency. Jones and the Yankees are giving us HYPE with the Ohtani references and the great endorsements from Aaron Judge. We are way past promise of things to come. Now we need to see the high level of execution at the minor league level to earn the nig league call up.

And that’s still where I stand today. In four years playing minor league ball, he’s had 1,493 at bats and 554 strikeouts. His last two seasons have 379 of those 554 strikeouts. There’s still some work there to do. The Yankees outfield is crowded. Even if it weren’t crowded, and there was an opportunity to give him a clearly defined role….I’m just not there. He’s not in a spot to help the Yankees.

That’s a tough reality. I’m tired of watching these high strikeout guys that give us all or nothing. When they come up big it’s great, but when they don’t it is a massive failure in a clutch moment. It’s not enjoyable to watch these high strikeout guys that we know have flaws at the big league level and just hope those flaws don’t get exposed. We are at the point where athleticism and performance have evolved, but baseball fundamentals and smart play has become less important or emphasized. For me, Jones is not big league ready. He struggles down in the minors, it’s not going to get easier for him when he has to face elite pitching. Giving him a promotion to the big leagues with these stats would only be doing him a disservice because we aren’t setting him up for success.

–Jeana Bellezza-Ochoa

BYB Senior Managing Editor

Twitter: @nyprincessj